Posted 2008-December-11, 19:40
As I said before, any payment - any payment at all - on every email kills RSS feeds and high-volume mailing lists.
And by high-volume, we're talking 200 people or so. The Bridge-Laws Mailing List had 50 individual posters last month, and by SWAG, another 50 who just read, and didn't post (either because they don't, or because nothing in November interested them). 739 messages total. 73 900 emails (give or take 40 000). $73.90 somebody has to pay - just for the month. And I bet most of you have never heard of that mailing list, even though you're all bridge players!
I used to be on the ASL ML, same thing there - and maybe two of you know what Advanced Squad Leader is, never mind that there's a mailing list for it.
If things this obscure are rattling up $1000/year bills, they're dying. Automatically. And there are Not-Obscure mailing lists, with email counts 10, 100 times as big (one that come to mind right away are linux-kernel (5000+ members, 200-300 messages a *day*) and debian-user (1500 members, 2500 messages a month)). 0.1c/email = $10000/month.
How big can an RSS feed get? Every CNN story, sent to (let's be really conservative) 20 000 people (it wouldn't surprise me if that's off by an order of magnitude)? Remember, that's $20/story. What, 100 stories/updates a day? Anybody got a spare $50 000+ a month to play with? Neither does CNN. Bye-bye RSS feed.
And to the internet, there's little difference between gobbledygook like "/dev/sdb1 /srv/img0 ext3 noatime,nodev,nosuid 0 2" and "Make Pneis Now!", when it's sent to 5000 users at a time. So how do we tell what is "legitimate" and what is "spam"?
Long live the Republic-k. -- Major General J. Golding Frederick (tSCoSI)