barmar, on 2019-August-29, 10:10, said:
If the industry opposes easing of regulations, doesn't that suggest that they'll voluntarily comply with the old standards? It's not like Trump is forcing them to pollute more. Reducing regulations just means they don't have to spend the resources dealing with regulators to show that they're meeting the requirements.
Kind of like when he pulled out of the Paris Accord, many states and companies said they would continue to work towards meeting those standards. Not everything has to be forced by the federal government.
This was also McConnell's argument for why he's not bringing legislation about election security to the Senate floor, he claims this should be handled at the state level, not federal level. He's probably lying, because he knows that this won't happen adequately and election insecurity favors the GOP, but it's not an unreasonable argument on its face. A major plank of the Republican platform is reduced federal oversight.
Only part of the industry opposes the new rule, including major players Shell and Exxon. According to E.A. Crunden at ThinkProgress: "Shell executive Gretchen Watkins asserted that her company plans to continue reducing its methane emissions, with a goal of cutting its net carbon footprint 50% by mid-century". So, perhaps some major players will continue to play by the old rule. While it's safe to say that most Republicans favor reduced oversight, former EPA administrator under Nixon and Reagan, William Ruckleshaus, said this in an NYT op-ed a couple years ago:
Quote
A strong and credible regulatory regime is essential to the smooth functioning of our economy. Unless people believe their health and the environment are being safeguarded, they will withdraw their permission for companies to do business. The chemical industry executives who came in to see me that day felt this loss of public support and were asking me to reassure Americans that the government would do its job to protect them.
Our collective freedom and well-being depends on a set of restraints that govern society and how it operates. Those restraints need to be clear and effective.
If you lose all hope, you can always find it again -- Richard Ford in The Sportswriter