Here we have a hand that took place in a team match with a BBO "expert" and advanced player partnership. E/W were silent. North began
1H 1S
3C 3S
4D 5C
5N all pass result +660 for a loss of 17 imps.
My thoughts of the bidding were that 3C was a stretch as this is not exactly what I would consider a hand to j/s. 4D was a cue bid for S of course but now clearly a massive overbid considering we have already j/s and for my money 4S would have been adequate at this point. No matter what 5N was supposed to be S simply must not pass.
The opening lead was made and the first swing was from N landing a blow to the lower body, followed with a uppercut, and I think even a kick! S regained footing and delivered a solid blow or so himself but neither player was anxious to admit fault. The reached for pistols and one player was wonded, not seriously we hope.
Lets hear what your thoughts are where and what made this accident take place. If you would also suggest a torture for the guilty party that wouold be appreciated.
Thanks