blackshoe, on 2012-August-11, 12:56, said:
Why is redouble horrible, Kathryn?
If rdbl showed 5+ spades and 11+ hcp then it is not horrible of course.
1x-DBL-1Y F1 and 4+
There are hands you may decide to start RDBL, but you do that when you are expecting them to have no good fit and/or planning to punish them. Kathryn was polite when she said RDBL was horrible, you don't wanna hear my opinion about the RDBL in this auction.
RDBL is horrible because
-You are letting your LHO bid his
♥ suit at 1 level
-You are taking the risk of being preempted before you get to introduce your suit.
-Because of delaying to bid your suit, you will waste space in your next turn(s)
-Because of introducing your suit later, you will also have to introduce your fit in diamond later ( or you will have to hide it)
-RDBL may immediately show your strength but i don't know why people think this is important especially when their hand has lot more stories to tell to pd and starting with your natural bid DOES NOT deny the strength you hold anyway.
-It is horrible because this hand is neither strong enough to make GF and introduce his suit+ his support later, nor has any penalty plans before 4 level by opponents.
-RDBL disables your side from using DBL conveniently if auction gets competitive, due to the nature of RDBL.
Everyone has their own ways, mine is simple, jump shift by responder is fit showing and inv+ in competition and/or by passed hand.
1
♦-X-2
♠ shows my 5 card spade + 4 card diamond + my values. It aint perfect i know. Some people play xfers responses. But playing 1 level suits as limited and NF and redoubling with all 10+ hcps or whatever their limit is, worse than horrible imo.