Texas Transfer Question
#4
Posted 2013-July-01, 12:37
#10
Posted 2013-July-02, 02:52
In most countries I've played in + US, 3M is usually played as something with minors (this is just my impression). I like 3M as a forcing slam try for what it's worth but I've never seen it in real life. Anyway, for the people who don't play 3M as a forcing slam try or something with transfers, transfer then 4M is not really a mild slam try.
... and I can prove it with my usual, flawless logic.
George Carlin
George Carlin
#11
Posted 2013-July-02, 03:00
barsikb, on 2013-July-01, 12:44, said:
Thank you!
What about 1NT-2D-2H-4NT
Opener has options of Pass, 6H, 6NT. Is there also option of 5H meaning that we have no slam but I'd rather play in Hearts than in NT even though I need to go to a higher level?
What about 1NT-2D-2H-4NT
Opener has options of Pass, 6H, 6NT. Is there also option of 5H meaning that we have no slam but I'd rather play in Hearts than in NT even though I need to go to a higher level?
A word of caution. I would estimate that 90% of players on BBO bidding 4NT here (arguably incorrectly) would mean this to be is Blackwood. The vast majority of the remaining 10% that meant the bid to be quantitative would when hearing a replay of 5♥ would hedging their bets take it it be a reply to Key card/Blackwood.
I notice that the title of this thread is "Replying to texas transfer question" and yet there is nothing here on Texas transfers.
1NT-4♦ or 1NT-4♥ are texas transfers to 4♥/♠ respectively. Thus 1NT-2♦-2♥-4♥ gives you a sequence with some slam interest and 1NT-4♦-4♥ gives you a sequence with no slam interest. The exception with the latter is that if as responder you are so strong that all you want to know is how many key cards partner opened with, then you can follow the Texas transfer with 4NT key card. Texas transfers are not univerally popular.
May 2003: Mission accomplished
Oct 2006: Mission impossible
Soon: Mission illegal
Oct 2006: Mission impossible
Soon: Mission illegal
#12
Posted 2013-July-02, 03:05
What is it then? If your one-suited ladder looks like this:-
1NT - 4red; 4M = to play
1NT - 3M = strong slam interest
1NT - 4red; 4M - any = slam drive,
it is entirely logical to play 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M as a mild slam try, fitting in-between the first two sequences.
1NT - 4red; 4M = to play
1NT - 3M = strong slam interest
1NT - 4red; 4M - any = slam drive,
it is entirely logical to play 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M as a mild slam try, fitting in-between the first two sequences.
(-: Zel :-)
#13
Posted 2013-July-05, 04:51
Zelandakh, on 2013-July-02, 03:05, said:
What is it then? If your one-suited ladder looks like this:-
1NT - 4red; 4M = to play
1NT - 3M = strong slam interest
1NT - 4red; 4M - any = slam drive,
it is entirely logical to play 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M as a mild slam try, fitting in-between the first two sequences.
1NT - 4red; 4M = to play
1NT - 3M = strong slam interest
1NT - 4red; 4M - any = slam drive,
it is entirely logical to play 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M as a mild slam try, fitting in-between the first two sequences.
It is indeed entirely logical, I've already said as much in my previous post. But it's not standard from what I have seen. This is the BWS for instance: http://www.bridgewor...bwsall.html#IVF (for what little it is worth, of course, not saynig that it is gospel). They do not call transfer then 4M as a mild slam try.
... and I can prove it with my usual, flawless logic.
George Carlin
George Carlin
#14
Posted 2013-July-05, 05:09
gwnn, on 2013-July-05, 04:51, said:
It is indeed entirely logical, I've already said as much in my previous post. But it's not standard from what I have seen. This is the BWS for instance: http://www.bridgewor...bwsall.html#IVF (for what little it is worth, of course, not saynig that it is gospel). They do not call transfer then 4M as a mild slam try.
That is because they are playing 3M responses as splinters, so 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M is the only one-suited slam try without splintering. I do not think this is standard amongst beginners.
(-: Zel :-)
#15
Posted 2013-July-05, 06:33
Zelandakh, on 2013-July-05, 05:09, said:
That is because they are playing 3M responses as splinters, so 1NT - 2red; 2M - 4M is the only one-suited slam try without splintering. I do not think this is standard amongst beginners.
Nor are Texas transfers.
... and I can prove it with my usual, flawless logic.
George Carlin
George Carlin